The Chronicles of Narnia Wiki

Welcome to WikiNarnia! Please check out the Community Page and get involved in our current projects or head to Discussions to talk with other Narnia fans.

READ MORE

The Chronicles of Narnia Wiki
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 6: Line 6:
 
I liked the few changes made to LWW, however, I found Prince Caspian not so likeable. The added castle battle was unnecessary, and the Susan/Caspian romance was bad, as was Peter's attitude. {{User:Arvan Swordwielder/sig}}
 
I liked the few changes made to LWW, however, I found Prince Caspian not so likeable. The added castle battle was unnecessary, and the Susan/Caspian romance was bad, as was Peter's attitude. {{User:Arvan Swordwielder/sig}}
 
----
 
----
  +
There weren't any changes in LWW that really bugged me, I think all of the worked and helped the story flow better on screen. As a film, I thought PC was better, but only in that isolated aspect. The attack on Miraz's castle may have been unnecessary, but it was wicked cool, so I'd let it slide. The Peter/Caspian power struggle was just stupid and completely contrary to both their characters. The Susan/Caspian thing was lame. There was no point to it, and they didn't even set it up very well. {{User:Rain Thalo/sig}}

Revision as of 20:19, 26 August 2009

Forums: Index > WikiNarnia forum > Book vs. Movies



There are major differences between the books and their current movie addaptions. What do you think about the differences, good/bad/unnecessary? EdmundtheJustsig (1)



I liked the few changes made to LWW, however, I found Prince Caspian not so likeable. The added castle battle was unnecessary, and the Susan/Caspian romance was bad, as was Peter's attitude. ArvanSwordwielderSigArvanSwordwielderSigTalk


There weren't any changes in LWW that really bugged me, I think all of the worked and helped the story flow better on screen. As a film, I thought PC was better, but only in that isolated aspect. The attack on Miraz's castle may have been unnecessary, but it was wicked cool, so I'd let it slide. The Peter/Caspian power struggle was just stupid and completely contrary to both their characters. The Susan/Caspian thing was lame. There was no point to it, and they didn't even set it up very well. --  Rain Thalo  talk  contribs  edits  email